architecture comparisons

[Frank E. Ritter]

Gary Jones has written up a comparison between Soar and ActR. The 
long version is available on the web
in the ONREUR Newsletter, and a more condensed version was published in AISBQ:

Jones G. (1996). The
architectures of Soar and ACT-R, and how they model human behaviour. 
Artificial Intelligence and
Simulation of Behaviour Quarterly, Winter 1996, 96, 41-44.

(if it's not longer at http://www.ehis.navy.mil:80/gjones.htm, them 
email Gary at G.Jones at derby.ac.uk)


Pew & Mavor, of course.


Ritter, F. E., Shadbolt, N. R., Elliman, D., Young, R., Gobet, F., & 
Baxter, G. D. (2001). Techniques for modeling human performance in 
synthetic environments: A supplementary review. Wright-Patterson Air 
Force Base, OH: Human Systems Information Analysis Center.

This is just about in page proofs.  I can pass you the tech report 
now, or the pageproofs, late late this week or by the end of June.

Cheers,

Frank



>Folks,
>
>I am seeking published (or in press) papers that compare computational
>cognitive modeling architectures.  An example of this is the comparison of
>production system architectures in chapter 12 of The Atomic Components of
>Thought.  Another example is Todd Johnson's 1997 paper on Control in ACT-R
>and Soar, and also Newell, Rosenbloom, and Laird's (1989) comparison of Soar
>and ACT*.
>
>Also of interest are papers that compare the features and/or predictions of
>two or more models created in different modeling architectures.
>
>I am not restricting my search to papers that involve ACT-R.  If you know of
>any papers that fit either of the descriptions above (and that are not the
>thre




>e already mentioned), I would very much appreciate your replying with a
>reference, softcopy, or point of contact.
>
>Many thanks,
>
>Kevin
>
>----------------------------------------------
>Kevin A. Gluck, PhD
>Air Force Research Laboratory
>Warfighter Training Research Division
>6030 S. Kent St.
>Mesa, AZ  85212-6061
>Tel: 480-988-6561 ext. 234 / DSN 474-6234
>Fax: 480-988-6285

-- 

Frank  Ritter at ist.psu.edu
School of Information Sciences and Technology
The Pennsylvania State University
512 Rider
University Park, PA  16801-3857
ph.  (814) 865-4453   fax (814) 865-5604
http://ritter.ist.psu.edu