"Blind" reviews are impossible

Gary Cottrell gary at cs.ucsd.edu
Tue Dec 20 18:29:18 EST 1994


Right, silly euphemisms work, or simply saying, "prior work on this
by cottrell, etc." The year I was on the NIPS PC, I was also on
the PC for ACL and AAAI. ACL used blind reviewing. I was sure I was
reviewing a paper by Ken Church, and I was wrong. There was only one
paper of the 15 or so I reviewed that I had any idea who it was.

gary cottrell



More information about the Connectionists mailing list