reviewer comments about cognitive modeling

[Christian Schunn]

Dieter Wallach and I are writing a paper addressing common complaints 
about computational cognitive modeling (theoretical and pragmatic). 
We would greatly appreciate any anecdotes or quotes that you could 
provide from journal or conference reviews on this topic (to 
demonstrate that these complaints exist in the world rather than just 
in our heads and to document the relative frequency of the complaint 
types). Obviously, the reviewer's (or editor's) identity would have 
to be kept anonymous, but if you could identify the journal (or 
conference) or at least the type of journal (psych, cog sci, comp 
sci, etc), that would be great. To make things easier on you, you can 
send us whole reviews, and we can find the relevant bits.

Thanks in advance,

-Chris
-----------------------------
Christian Schunn
Assistant Professor of Psychology
George Mason University

Currently visiting the University of Basel in Switzerland

Best contact method: schunn at gmu.edu
Web: www.hfac.gmu.edu/~schunn
-----------------------------